RonO (rono_60103) wrote,

Looking in a Crystal Ball

I foresee sometime next winter, on the SMOFs list and possibly elsewhere, a great debate about what Hugo category a particular work belongs.

You see, sent me an e-mail (I’ve been a customer/subscriber of theirs for years) announcing “…Audible presents the first Polish-to-English translation of Stanislaw Lem’s Solaris, endorsed by the author’s estate, and available only in digital audio.” {bold face  mine for emphasis}

Therefore, next year during Hugo Award nomination season, there will be great debate  whether this qualifies for “Best Novel” or “Dramatic Presentation, Long Form.”  Some will argue that since it is an audio book it is inherently a dramatic presentation and must be nominated in that category.  Others will argue either (1) that the fact that it is (first) presented in an audio format is not withstanding and the writing should be nominated or (2) that as a dramatic presentation it is not one of the best of the year.

While I know where I’d likely land – at least having not yet read the book/listened to the audio – I’m not going to share that here.

Of course, if there was an abridged or unauthorized translation earlier, then it might not be eligible for novel since that would probably make it not qualify for the “first time in English” {approximate quote}, which would make at least one argument moot.



  • Life Report/Trip Report

    When last I posted way at the other end of this surprisingly long February, I had a job, and a potential house.  Since then, Tara and I have packed…

  • Life Updates

    For the few people who only see my updates from my blog (or LiveJournal which mirrors my blog), here are a couple of updates on my life: 1: I have…

  • Transitions

    This morning, I was called into a meeting with my bosses boss.  As soon as he asked for the meeting, I was pretty sure what the meeting was about,…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment